Good Old Days Resort

Introduction / Overview

For those in Wisconsin seeking a classic resort experience, the Good Old Days Resort in Montello offers a perfect slice of lakeside living. This is more than just a hotel; it's a destination that embodies the quintessential Wisconsin vacation, with a focus on relaxation, outdoor fun, and delicious food. Situated on the shores of Lake Puckaway, the resort provides a nostalgic and cozy atmosphere that has made it a go-to spot for many locals for years. While some past reviews may have expressed concerns about service or food quality, many guests continue to praise the resort for its great service, amazing food, and its role as a cherished "go to spot" when visiting the lake. The resort is known for its cabin and duplex-style lodging, offering a more rustic, home-like feel than a traditional hotel room. It's a place where families can create lasting memories, whether it's through fishing on the lake, enjoying a meal at the on-site restaurant, or simply relaxing in the peaceful natural surroundings. The friendly staff and a commitment to providing a memorable experience are what keep guests coming back year after year, reinforcing its reputation as a beloved local gem in central Wisconsin.

Location and Accessibility

The Good Old Days Resort is located at W983 W North Shore Dr, Montello, WI 53949. Its location on the North Shore of Lake Puckaway provides a serene and picturesque setting that is both a destination in itself and a convenient base for exploring the area. For residents of Wisconsin, the resort is easily accessible via major roadways, making it a stress-free drive from larger cities. Montello is a charming town known for its natural beauty, and the resort's position on the lake allows guests to fully immerse themselves in the local environment. It's a prime spot for fishing enthusiasts, as Lake Puckaway is well-known for its abundance of fish species. The resort's location also places it within a reasonable driving distance of other popular Wisconsin destinations, such as the Wisconsin Dells, providing guests with a variety of nearby attractions to explore. The resort itself is situated in a way that feels private and secluded, yet it remains easy to find and navigate to. This blend of tranquility and accessibility makes it an ideal spot for a quick weekend escape or a longer, more immersive vacation, all within the heart of Wisconsin's beautiful landscape.

Services Offered

The Good Old Days Resort provides a wide array of services and amenities that are focused on creating a full and enjoyable resort experience. These offerings cater to guests of all ages and interests, from outdoor adventurers to those looking for a relaxing retreat.

• On-Site Restaurant and Bar: The resort features a full restaurant and bar that is open year-round. It is famous for its Friday all-you-can-eat fish fry and Saturday prime rib specials, making it a local dining destination.
• Resort-Style Lodging: Guests can choose from a variety of spacious and comfortable accommodations, including cabins and duplexes, which come with full kitchens and separate living areas, providing a true home-away-from-home feel.
• Heated Swimming Pool: The resort boasts a heated pool for guests to enjoy, offering a great way to cool off or relax after a day of activities.
• Lake Access and Recreation: As a lakefront property, the resort provides excellent opportunities for fishing, swimming, and boating on Lake Puckaway. Some rentals may even include a fishing boat.
• Game Room: A well-furnished game room provides a fun space for kids and adults to play, regardless of the weather.
• Complimentary Continental Breakfast: Guests are treated to a free continental breakfast, a convenient and delicious way to start each day.
• On-Site Laundry Facilities: The resort has a laundry room available for guests, which is a key convenience for those on longer stays.
• Outdoor Activities: The resort offers a private beach, a playground for children, a volleyball court, and lawn games, ensuring there's always something to do outside.

Features / Highlights

The Good Old Days Resort is celebrated for several key features that make it a unique and appealing destination for a Wisconsin getaway. These highlights are what guests often remember and praise most about their stay.

• Authentic Wisconsin Resort Experience: This resort offers the classic, nostalgic feel of an old-fashioned Wisconsin vacation, with cozy cabins, a lakeside restaurant, and plenty of outdoor activities.
• Renowned On-Site Dining: The restaurant and bar are a major highlight, with many locals and visitors considering it a "go to spot" for its amazing food, especially the prime rib and Friday fish fry.
• Spacious and Home-Like Accommodations: The cabins and duplexes are described as being clean, spacious, and equipped with amenities like full kitchens and living rooms, providing a comfortable environment for families and groups.
• Heated Pool and Lakeside Activities: The combination of a heated pool and direct access to Lake Puckaway for swimming and fishing offers the best of both worlds for water recreation.
• Friendly and Attentive Staff: Many guests consistently praise the staff for their great service and friendly demeanor, which enhances the overall positive experience at the resort.
• Great Value: The resort is often noted for being very affordable, providing an excellent value for the amenities and experience it offers, including the unique perk of a fishing boat with some rentals.
• Family-Friendly Environment: With a playground, game room, and a variety of outdoor activities, the resort is perfectly suited for families looking for a fun and engaging vacation spot.

Contact Information

For inquiries, reservations, or to learn more about the amenities and available lodging options, you can contact the Good Old Days Resort directly. The staff is ready to help you plan your ideal Montello getaway.

Address: W983 W North Shore Dr, Montello, WI 53949, USA

Phone: Note: Public data for this resort's phone number varies. For the most accurate and up-to-date information, please search online or check their official website for direct contact details.

Conclusion: Why this place is suitable for locals

For residents of Wisconsin, the Good Old Days Resort is the perfect place to reconnect with the state's beloved traditions of lakeside vacations. It’s an ideal option for families looking for a convenient and affordable "staycation" without the stress of long-distance travel. If you're a local who loves fishing, the resort’s location on Lake Puckaway is a dream come true. The on-site restaurant is a true community hub, and even if you're not staying at the resort, it's a place you can visit for a fantastic Friday fish fry or a Saturday prime rib dinner, making it a treasured local institution. The accommodations, with their home-like amenities, are great for hosting out-of-town family in a beautiful setting, allowing everyone to enjoy the natural beauty of Montello. While there may be some variability in guest experiences, the long-standing positive reputation for service and food among many locals speaks for itself. It’s a place that offers a genuine, classic Wisconsin experience, making it a proud local choice for a resort getaway.