Grayhaven Motel

For those seeking a distinctive and memorable "Hotels Near Me" experience in Ithaca, New York, the Grayhaven Motel stands out as a truly unique and cherished destination. Located at 657 Elmira Rd, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA, this lovingly restored vintage motor lodge offers a refreshing alternative to conventional hotel stays, blending historic charm with modern comforts and a deep connection to nature. You can reach them by phone at (607) 272-6434 or +1 607-272-6434.

The Grayhaven Motel's environment is arguably its most compelling feature, setting it apart as a true nature retreat. Nestled on over 11 acres of pristine woodlands, forests, and wetlands, the property is a haven for wildlife and a stop on the northeastern bird migration flyway. Guests describe the location as "so beautiful," offering direct access to acres of woodland trails for walking and exploration. This immersive natural setting provides a sense of peace and seclusion, despite being remarkably convenient to Ithaca's main attractions.

Its strategic location between Buttermilk Falls State Park and Robert H. Treman State Park means guests are just a short walk or drive from some of the Finger Lakes region's most iconic waterfalls and gorges. The motel is less than a mile from Buttermilk Falls, offering immediate access to hiking trails and natural beauty. This proximity to outdoor recreation, including swimming, hiking, fishing, hunting, and cross-country skiing, makes it an ideal base for adventurers and nature lovers seeking "Hotels Near Me" with an outdoor focus. The grounds themselves are thoughtfully designed with outdoor furniture, picnic areas, and beautifully maintained gardens, inviting guests to relax and connect with the serene surroundings.

The service at Grayhaven Motel consistently receives glowing reviews, often described as "wonderful" and "the best." The staff is praised for their friendliness, helpfulness, and ability to personalize each stay. Guests feel "treated like family" and highlight the exceptional communication from the owners, underscoring a hands-on, small-business approach where pride in guest satisfaction is evident. While the front desk operates during limited hours (daily from 8:00 AM - 7:00 PM), contactless check-in and check-out options are available, offering flexibility for arrivals.

The motel offers a range of complimentary services that enhance the guest experience. These include free self-parking (with spaces directly in front of rooms), free high-speed Wi-Fi in both public areas and rooms (with speeds ideal for multiple devices), and a complimentary "on-the-go" breakfast served daily from 8:00 AM to 10:00 AM. This breakfast often features regionally sourced items like local yogurt, granola, and oatmeal. Guests also appreciate the complimentary firewood and s'mores supplies, fostering a warm, communal atmosphere around the outdoor fire pits. Luggage storage is available, and for those seeking local guidance, guidebooks, recommendations, and local maps are provided.

Grayhaven Motel offers a distinctive array of features that contribute to its unique appeal. The motel, with its origins as a boarding house in 1919, boasts a rich history and rooms that have been "thoughtfully restored with period fixtures and modern amenities." Guests describe the rooms as "cozy, super-cute," "clean and comfy," and "spacious," with a "classic and spacious mid-century design." Many rooms feature wood-paneled walls and vaulted ceilings, contributing to a charming, vintage-modern feel. Specific amenities that guests particularly enjoy include:

• Vinyl record players, adding a nostalgic and unique entertainment element.
• Private bathrooms with natural bath products, hair dryers, and complimentary toiletries.
• Air conditioning and heating for year-round comfort.
• Flat-screen TVs with digital channels and streaming services.
• Work desks and chairs, and often laptop-friendly workspaces.
• Kitchenettes or full kitchens in some suites and cottages, equipped with cookware, dishware, utensils, refrigerators, and microwaves, ideal for longer stays or self-catering.
• Hypo-allergenic bedding and comfortable memory foam mattresses, ensuring a good night's sleep.

Beyond the rooms, the property offers a wealth of communal features that foster a relaxed and engaging atmosphere. These include multiple outdoor fire pits, barbecue grills, picnic areas, and a communal living room with a fireplace, perfect for socializing or unwinding. For active guests, there's a bocce court and croquet, along with a playground for children. The motel's commitment to sustainability is evident through its eco-friendly practices, such as eliminating single-use plastics, using refillable toiletry bottles, collecting rainwater, and focusing on energy conservation with LED lighting and efficient machines. They also prioritize responsible sourcing, with all food and drink offerings regionally sourced from within New York State, and linens made in the USA.

A notable feature is the integration of local art, with art events and temporary art galleries often hosted, showcasing works by local artists. The motel also runs an artist-in-residency program for various creative fields, further embedding it within the local cultural scene. Certain room types are dog-friendly, allowing guests to bring up to two pets for a fee, a highly valued amenity for many travelers.

The Grayhaven Motel positions itself as a premier "Hotels Near Me" option for those seeking an authentic Ithaca experience that combines relaxation, outdoor adventure, and a touch of local charm. Its blend of cozy accommodations and extensive outdoor amenities makes it ideal for families, couples, and individual travelers alike. The complimentary s'mores and fire pits are particularly popular with families, offering a classic campfire experience that creates lasting memories.

The motel's superb location ensures that guests are "next to everything you need." It's just a mile down the road from shopping and dining options, and a convenient 10-minute drive from Cornell University and Ithaca College. This accessibility makes it a practical choice for those visiting the universities for academic or family reasons. Beyond the immediate vicinity, guests can easily explore downtown Ithaca, with its vibrant Commons, diverse restaurants, and unique shops. Other nearby attractions include the Sciencenter, Herbert F. Johnson Museum of Art, and the Museum of the Earth.

The Grayhaven Motel is especially promoted for its appeal as a "haven away from home," emphasizing simple, casual comfort and an unpretentious atmosphere. Its commitment to a "living wage" for employees also adds to its positive community impact. Whether guests are looking for a base for hiking and exploring the Finger Lakes waterfalls, a cozy retreat for a romantic getaway, or a unique spot for a family vacation, Grayhaven Motel offers a distinctive and highly-rated option that leaves guests saying, "I'd never stay anywhere else!"