Montauk Manor

For individuals and families searching for "Hotels Near Of Me" in the picturesque hamlet of Montauk, New York, the Montauk Manor presents itself as a truly distinguished and historic resort experience. Located at 236 Edgemere St, Montauk, NY 11954, this magnificent establishment can be reached by phone at (631) 668-4400 or +1 631-668-4400. Montauk Manor isn't just a place to stay; it's a destination steeped in history and designed for relaxation and enjoyment, offering a unique blend of grand architecture and modern resort conveniences.

The Montauk Manor is a visual masterpiece, designed in the elegant Tudor Revival style and dating back to its original construction in 1926 by Carl G. Fisher, a visionary industrialist responsible for developing Miami Beach. This historic resort hotel sits majestically atop Signal Hill, offering guests unparalleled panoramic views of Gardiner's Bay, the Atlantic Ocean, and even Block Island Sound. The sprawling 12-acre property is adorned with meticulously landscaped gardens, providing a serene and picturesque backdrop for any stay. The building itself, with its striking Tudor architecture and grand interior spaces, including a lobby with original slate floors and two grand fireplaces, transports guests to a bygone era of luxury and sophistication. It was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1984, cementing its status as a significant historical landmark. Despite its historical grandeur, the atmosphere is described as quiet and relaxed, appealing to both families and older couples seeking a peaceful getaway outside the busiest parts of Montauk, yet close enough to access the town's attractions easily.

Montauk Manor operates as a 140-apartment resort condominium hotel, meaning the rooms are typically condo-style units. This is a significant feature, as it means guests often find their accommodations to be spacious and well-appointed, moving beyond typical hotel rooms. Many units include fully equipped kitchens with refrigerators, stovetops, ovens, microwaves, dishwashers, and all necessary kitchenware and utensils, allowing for self-catering and a more home-like experience. These units can range from studios to deluxe three-bedroom suites, many featuring separate living and dining areas, flat-screen TVs with cable channels, and in-room safes. Quality bedding and linens are consistently noted in reviews, ensuring a comfortable night's sleep. Many units also boast private balconies or terraces, offering guests the chance to enjoy the stunning Montauk views directly from their rooms. The noise level within the hotel is generally very low, contributing to a peaceful stay, even for rooms facing the pool and ocean. Daily housekeeping services are provided, and in-room massages can be requested, adding to the convenience and luxury.

The Montauk Manor prides itself on offering a wide array of services and amenities designed to enhance the guest experience. For recreation and wellness, the resort features both a magnificent heated outdoor swimming pool and a heated indoor pool, perfect for year-round enjoyment. A hot tub, saunas, and a day spa offering massages and various treatments are also available for ultimate relaxation. For the active traveler, there is a well-equipped fitness center, which, while described as "tiny," provides everything needed for a functional workout, including treadmills, weight machines, cycling machines, step machines, and even Peloton bikes. Outdoor enthusiasts can take advantage of the three synthetic tennis courts, a putting green, basketball court, bocce, and shuffleboard courts. The property also includes barbecue areas on the expansive lawn, ideal for communal meals. While the hotel's main restaurant is not directly affiliated with the resort, guests consistently report that the on-site restaurant (Monte's restaurant) offers plentiful, fresh meals with good service. For convenience, the resort offers complimentary wireless internet access in public areas, a 24-hour front desk, and a business center with meeting facilities. A highly valued service is the complimentary shuttle into downtown Montauk and various beaches throughout the day, making it easy for guests to explore the area without needing their own car, though plentiful parking is also available on premises, including an electric car charging station.

Montauk Manor frequently offers special packages to attract guests, such as "Stay 4 consecutive nights and pay for only 3 nights" or "Stay 7 consecutive nights and pay for only 6 nights," providing excellent value, particularly during the off-season. These promotions are designed to encourage longer stays and allow guests to fully immerse themselves in the Montauk experience. The resort also hosts unique events like Murder Mystery Weekends, adding an exciting dimension to a stay. Customer reviews consistently highlight the hotel's positive aspects: guests praise the kind and helpful staff, the seamless check-in and check-out process, and the overall beauty of the hotel and its surroundings. Many express a strong desire to return, often describing their stays as "fantastic" and the hotel as "marvelous." The spacious condo-style rooms with full kitchens are frequently cited as a major advantage, offering "great bang for your buck." The free shuttle service is an "unexpected surprise" that proves very useful, especially during the off-season. Guests recommend paying extra for deluxe rooms to enjoy the "beautiful view," indicating the stunning vistas are well worth the investment. While some reviews mention limited dining options during the off-season or a lack of convenience stores on site, the proximity to downtown Montauk (a short drive or shuttle ride) largely mitigates these minor points. The positive sentiment around the comfort of the beds, the low noise levels, and the overall peaceful environment consistently make Montauk Manor a highly recommended choice for those seeking "Hotels Near Of Me" in the Montauk area.