The Fenway House Hotel ico

The Fenway House Hotel

Hotels Near Of MeWisconsinGrant CountyFennimoreLincoln Avenue

1096 Lincoln Ave, Fennimore, WI 53809, USA

4.0

Nice hotel, reasonably priced. If you appreciate thoughtful decor that resembles an old hotel, this place is for you. Our room was comfortable and quiet. Our room had a nice two person jacuzzi tub and queen bed. The bed was soft for us, but comfortable. If you're in Fennimore for the night, this is the place to stay. Easy walking distance to restaurants, bars. And a great ice cream shop!

Woody Steinhoff
  • Overview
  • (608) 822-3782
  • fenwayhousehotel.com

The Fenway House Hotel Introduce

For those of us who call Wisconsin home, there's a special appreciation for places that combine rich history with genuine hospitality. The Fenway House Hotel in Fennimore is one such place, offering a memorable stay that is far from the cookie-cutter experience of a modern chain hotel. This historic establishment, previously known as the Silent Woman, has been thoughtfully restored and is now under new management, breathing new life into a local landmark. It stands as a testament to the old-world charm of the region, with its original masonry, beautiful woodwork, and century-old terrazzo floors creating an atmosphere of timeless elegance. The hotel is more than just a place to sleep; it’s an experience in itself, inviting guests to explore and appreciate the character and heritage of the building. With 13 uniquely decorated guest rooms, The Fenway House Hotel provides a variety of comfortable and quiet accommodations, making it a perfect spot for locals seeking a romantic getaway, a vacation with friends, or a peaceful stopover in the beautiful southwest corner of our state. The thoughtful design and attention to detail, as noted by guests who "appreciate thoughtful decor that resembles an old hotel," ensure that every stay feels special and distinct.

The Fenway House Hotel’s location in Fennimore makes it a highly convenient and accessible destination for local residents. Situated at 1096 Lincoln Ave, Fennimore, WI 53809, USA, the hotel is perfectly positioned in the heart of a charming small town. This central location means that, as one guest pointed out, it is within "easy walking distance to restaurants, bars. And a great ice cream shop!" This walkability is a major plus, allowing guests to explore the local area on foot and truly immerse themselves in the community. Fennimore is located in the heart of the Driftless Area, a unique and picturesque part of Wisconsin known for its rolling hills, scenic valleys, and outdoor recreation. While a car is necessary for exploring the wider region, the hotel's on-site amenities and proximity to downtown attractions make it an excellent base camp. The hotel is easily accessible from major roads, making the drive from places like Madison or La Crosse a straightforward journey. This blend of small-town charm and accessibility to both local haunts and the stunning natural landscape of the Driftless Area makes The Fenway House Hotel an ideal choice for a relaxing and convenient local getaway.

The Fenway House Hotel offers a range of services designed to make your stay as comfortable and stress-free as possible. The hotel prides itself on its personalized approach to hospitality, with a 24-hour front desk and a seamless check-in process, as experienced by a guest who "got there later in the evening and they made check in a breeze." The hotel's staff is known for being friendly and accommodating, ensuring that every guest feels welcome and cared for. For those who need to stay connected, complimentary high-speed Wi-Fi is available in all areas, providing a reliable connection for work or leisure. The hotel also offers a "grab and go" breakfast to help guests start their day right, with options like fresh fruit, yogurt, breakfast sausage, and freshly baked sweet rolls. For added convenience, housekeeping is available upon request, and there are vending machines for drinks and snacks. The hotel also features a hot tub, providing a perfect way to unwind after a day of exploring the town or the scenic surroundings. While there are a number of amenities available, it is important for guests to note that the rooms are all on the second floor of the historic building, which unfortunately does not have an elevator and is therefore not handicap accessible. This is a key piece of information that helps set proper expectations for a stay at this unique, historic property.

  • Unique and Thoughtfully Decorated Rooms: Each of the hotel's 13 rooms is individually designed and decorated, offering a distinct experience with old-world charm. Guests can choose from a variety of room types, including standard rooms, suites, and semi-suites, ensuring there is an option to suit different preferences and needs.
  • Whirlpool Tubs: Several rooms at The Fenway House Hotel feature large, two-person whirlpool tubs. This luxury amenity is a major highlight, perfect for a romantic getaway or for simply soaking and relaxing after a long day.
  • Cozy Amenities: All rooms come equipped with modern conveniences such as air conditioning, flat-screen TVs with cable channels, coffee/tea makers, and complimentary toiletries. Some rooms also have a mini-refrigerator and microwave, adding to the comfort and convenience.
  • Historical Character: The hotel’s authentic, historical decor and architecture, from its beautiful woodwork to its original terrazzo floors, create a unique and memorable ambiance that appeals to those who appreciate a stay that is rich in character and history.
  • Walkable Location: The hotel’s prime location on Lincoln Avenue places it within easy walking distance of local restaurants, bars, and shops, including a popular ice cream shop, making it a great home base for exploring Fennimore on foot.
  • On-Site Events and Services: The hotel has a banquet hall that is available for events, and they even occasionally host live music, creating a lively atmosphere for both guests and locals.

What makes The Fenway House Hotel particularly suitable for locals from Wisconsin is its ability to provide a one-of-a-kind experience that celebrates our state's heritage. The thoughtful decor and historic ambiance, as highlighted by a guest who found it to be a "very interesting place" they "loved exploring around," offer a refreshing change from the typical chain hotel experience. The hotel's cozy and quiet rooms, along with the availability of luxury amenities like a two-person jacuzzi tub in some units, cater to the desire for a relaxing and intimate escape. The personalized and friendly check-in process, as noted in a review, and the overall welcoming atmosphere make guests feel like they are part of the community, not just a temporary visitor. The hotel’s proximity to local businesses and attractions, from museums to outdoor recreation in the Driftless Area, means that a stay here can be as active or as low-key as you want it to be. This combination of historic charm, modern comfort, and a genuinely friendly atmosphere makes The Fenway House Hotel a true gem in Fennimore, and a perfect destination for Wisconsin residents looking for an authentic and memorable local getaway. It is a place that feels like a discovery, promising a unique and satisfying stay that is well worth the short drive.

Address: 1096 Lincoln Ave, Fennimore, WI 53809, USA

Phone: (608) 822-3782

The Fenway House Hotel Photos

The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4
The Fenway House Hotel 4

The Fenway House Hotel Location & Map

1096 Lincoln Ave, Fennimore, WI 53809, USA

Reviews

Nice hotel, reasonably priced. If you appreciate thoughtful decor that resembles an old hotel, this place is for you. Our room was comfortable and quiet. Our room had a nice two person jacuzzi tub and queen bed. The bed was soft for us, but comfortable. If you're in Fennimore for the night, this is the place to stay. Easy walking distance to restaurants, bars. And a great ice cream shop!

Aug 02, 2025 · Woody Steinhoff

We stayed here because we have family that live close by. We got there later in the evening and they made check in a breeze. The hotel is a very interesting place! We loved exploring around. We can't wait to stay here again

Aug 02, 2025 · Kirsten Voges

Awesome old school hotel (built in 1918). The place is modernized but still retains the old nostalgia feeling. Parker and Jamie are awesome as well. I travel for work extensively weeks at a time. Parker set my 2 son's (they work with me as well) and I up with a studio apartment room small and cozy makes us feel at home. Close to work and close to shops and other historical items/places. The towns folk are very friendly and welcoming as well. Will definitely be staying again. Definitely recommend a nights stay at the Fenway House Hotel. They also offer other amenities as well. Call them up and inquire, you definitely won't be disappointed.

Jun 06, 2025 · john bangs

This place is incredible! Such a perfect blend of historic and modern, with renovated rooms that still keep the hotels’ antique charm intact. The people here could not have been more friendly and our stay was comfortable and fun. If you’re in town, make sure to check out any concerts that come through the attached music venue and get coffee and lunch at Lemon Door next door!

Apr 16, 2025 · Sarah Wild

This place should be in Wisconsin and Midwest Top 10 lists for reasons you must see a place in person. I don't even know where to start. The owner was outstanding and super accommodating. We asked to switch rooms to one without carpet, and they cleaned one immediately for us. We got a tour of the entire ground floor. It includes an old restaurant that looks like a little village with a stream (soon to be) running through it, an old bar that was imported from France, and a banquet hall with a gold ceiling. The owner told us we could explore as much as we liked, and as you can see from the attached photos, I did just that. The rooms had decent wifi and TV with more channels than I have at home. We ended up signing into our YouTube account on the TV, though. To say our room was clean is an understatement. I've heard people describe bedsheets as "crisp" before, but now, I know what they're talking about. The rooms all use their own keypad entry, so there were no key cards to keep track of, thankfully. There's no breakfast, but there is coffee. You can use the free coffee to fuel your walks to one of the nearby cafes and restaurants. Two amazing places to eat within a block. Even more within a few blocks. I went looking for a quiet place to work one afternoon, and while there isn't a dedicated business center space, there is plenty of available space to work quietly in. Once again, the owner was happy to show me around and help me find a space that would work for me to get some emails sent and files edited. Overall, it's an amazing place, with phenomenal people staffing it, and I can't wait to go back to explore the hotel some more.

Mar 02, 2025 · Christina Streiff

Hotels Near Of Me

AmericInn by Wyndham Boscobel

AmericInn by Wyndham Boscobel

1700 Elm St, Boscobel, WI 53805, USA

Pine Grove Motel

Pine Grove Motel

1415 S Madison St, Lancaster, WI 53813, USA

Sleep Inn & Suites Lancaster

Sleep Inn & Suites Lancaster

1600 S Madison St, Lancaster, WI 53813, USA

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Platteville by IHG

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Platteville by IHG

55 S Elm St, Platteville, WI 53818, USA

Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Platteville, WI

Country Inn & Suites by Radisson, Platteville, WI

630 S Water St, Platteville, WI 53818, USA

Super 8 by Wyndham Platteville

Super 8 by Wyndham Platteville

100 Highway 80-81 South, Platteville, WI 53818, USA

Bagley Cabin In The Woods

Bagley Cabin In The Woods

12505 Cooley Ln, Bagley, WI 53801, USA

Anaway Place

Anaway Place

21558 Candlewood Ln, Richland Center, WI 53581, USA

Quality Inn & Suites Belmont Route 151

Quality Inn & Suites Belmont Route 151

103 W Mound View Ave, Belmont, WI 53510, USA

Bagley Hotel/Stella's Pizzeria and Lodging

Bagley Hotel/Stella's Pizzeria and Lodging

175 S Bagley Ave, Bagley, WI 53801, USA

AmericInn by Wyndham Prairie du Chien

AmericInn by Wyndham Prairie du Chien

37502 US-18, Prairie du Chien, WI 53821, USA

Windsor Place Inn

Windsor Place Inn

1936 S Marquette Rd, Prairie du Chien, WI 53821, USA