Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern

For local users in Mifflinburg, PA, and those traveling through the Susquehanna Valley, the "Hotels Near Of Me" category on various platforms serves as a crucial resource for finding suitable accommodation and dining options. The Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern, located at 264 Chestnut St, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, USA, stands as a prominent establishment that uniquely combines lodging with a lively culinary and social experience. You can reach them at (570) 966-5400 for reservations or inquiries. This introduction will provide an objective and detailed overview of this historic venue, covering its environment, services, features, and any available promotional information, drawing from its online presence and customer feedback.

The Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern is steeped in history, a significant aspect of its environment. Originally the site of the Stitzer Inn built in 1829, the current structure was erected in 1858 and has seen various iterations, including the Deckard Hotel, Union Hotel, and Hotel Hopp. After a devastating fire in 1916 and subsequent restoration, the hotel has evolved, at times serving as a temperance hotel, a banquet facility, and a boarding house. Extensive renovations completed in 2007 by the Buck family, known for restoring other historic properties like The Watson Inn and The Lewisburg Hotel, aimed to revive its original luster. This rich past contributes to a classic Victorian style that permeates the establishment, creating a unique atmosphere that newer venues cannot match. Situated on Chestnut Street, it is a focal point of the town, allowing guests and diners to experience Mifflinburg's historic charm. The Scarlet D Tavern, fondly known as "the D" by locals, features a distinctive two-story bar and is clearly a central part of the community's social fabric. This historical backdrop adds a layer of character and appeal beyond that of a standard, modern hotel.

The Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern offers a dual experience: accommodation and a vibrant dining and entertainment hub. The hotel portion provides 18 rooms, designed to reflect a classic Victorian style while incorporating modern amenities for guest comfort. Guests can expect air-conditioned accommodations that often include premium bedding, desks, irons/ironing boards, and complimentary toiletries. Many rooms feature flat-screen televisions with satellite channels, free Wi-Fi, and separate sitting areas. Some suites, such as the Luxury Suite and Honeymoon Suite, may offer additional features like kitchenettes with refrigerators, microwaves, and coffee/tea makers, and even jetted tubs in some Honeymoon Suites, catering to various guest needs, including those seeking longer stays or more luxurious options. While not an extended stay hotel, these in-room kitchen amenities provide added convenience.

The Scarlet D Tavern and its accompanying restaurant are significant features. The restaurant offers lunch and full dinner menus across four dining areas, with a capacity for banquets of up to 90 people. The Tavern itself boasts a unique two-story bar, large screen TVs for sports, and a wide selection of 11 different draught beers, along with various imported and domestic bottled beers. The menu is diverse, featuring pub favorites and more substantial entrees. Notable items frequently praised by customers include wings, burgers, freshly breaded chicken tenders, wraps, and especially the "fresh cut French fries." Specific daily specials are common, such as "Wing Nite" on Thursdays (5-10 pm) and "Haddock" specials on Fridays. They also offer "Surf and Turf" specials on Saturdays. Live entertainment is a regular occurrence in the tavern, making it a lively spot in Mifflinburg for a fun night out. The presence of encased, signed guitars, including one by Johnny Cash himself, adds a unique and fascinating touch to the tavern's ambiance.

Customer reviews overwhelmingly praise the dining and tavern experience at the Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern. The consistent theme across both provided reviews is the excellence of the food and the quality of service. Guests enthusiastically commend the "delicious" food, with specific shout-outs to the "Wings, burgers, freshly breaded chicken tenders, wraps" and the "fresh cut French fries" which received a "chef’s kiss." The food is consistently described as "piping hot" and "excellent." Beyond the food, the service receives equally high marks. Both reviewers highlight the "excellent" servers, with one specifically naming "MorganY" for her great recommendations. The overall sentiment is one of extreme satisfaction and a strong intent to "definitely return" or "will return." This indicates that the Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern has successfully cultivated a positive and memorable dining and social experience, making it a local favorite and a draw for visitors.

While the provided reviews focus heavily on the tavern and restaurant, the historical nature of the building and the dual function as a hotel imply that the accommodation aspect aims to match the quality of the dining. Guests would likely expect comfortable, clean rooms that reflect the described Victorian style, though no specific reviews for the hotel rooms are provided here. However, generally positive comments about the establishment as a whole suggest a well-maintained property.

The Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern's promotional strategy appears to leverage its historical charm, its reputation for excellent food, and its lively entertainment offerings. The "history" section on its website, detailing its past and the Buck family's dedication to restoration, serves as a strong narrative, inviting guests to experience a piece of Mifflinburg's heritage. The regular live entertainment and nightly food specials, such as Wing Night and Friday Haddock, are key draws for local patrons and visitors alike, encouraging repeat business and a dynamic atmosphere. The diverse menu, which includes both casual tavern fare and more substantial dinner options, caters to a broad clientele. The pride in its beer selection, with 11 draught beers, appeals to craft beer enthusiasts. The unique feature of signed guitars, including Johnny Cash's, provides a unique talking point and attraction. The "D" being "the place to be in Mifflinburg" is a direct promotional message reflecting its status as a community hub. The value proposition of the Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern lies in its ability to offer more than just a place to stay or eat; it provides a comprehensive experience encompassing history, delicious food, quality service, and vibrant local entertainment, making it a distinctive choice within the "Hotels Near Of Me" category for those seeking a richer local immersion.

For local users in Mifflinburg, PA, and surrounding areas searching within the "Hotels Near Of Me" category, the Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern at 264 Chestnut St, Mifflinburg, PA 17844, USA (phone: (570) 966-5400) offers a compelling combination of lodging and a highly-regarded dining and entertainment venue. This establishment is more than just a hotel; it's a piece of local history brought to life with modern comforts. The reviews unequivocally praise the Scarlet D Tavern for its delicious, hot food and exceptional service, positioning it as a top choice for meals and a social outing in Mifflinburg. While direct reviews for the hotel rooms are not available, the overall commitment to quality and the historical ambiance suggest a unique stay. For those looking for a comfortable place to rest, combined with a vibrant and welcoming dining and social atmosphere featuring live entertainment and excellent food, the Mifflinburg Hotel & Scarlet D Tavern stands out as a highly recommended and integrated experience in the heart of Mifflinburg.