The MC Hotel, Autograph Collection

Good hotel. Expensive but also high end. Great roof top with a great view. Staff is friendly and helpful. Room was clean and bed was comfortable. Bathroom was clean. However, I hate a sink that doesn't drain properly. The room was on the smaller size as well. Lobby bar and restaurant are good. Bar needs a better beer tap selection. Not wvery beer on tap should be a local IPA for 9 bucks. throw on a domestic as an option. Gym was small but adequate for the hotel. Location is prime. Walking distance to everything in town. Overall a nice place.

I had a wonderful stay at The MC Hotel, Autograph Collection! From the moment I arrived, the staff made me feel incredibly welcome. The design of the hotel is modern yet cozy, with beautiful touches that reflect the charm of Montclair. My room was spotless, spacious, and offered a stunning view of the skyline. One of the highlights was the rooftop bar—perfect for relaxing with a cocktail while enjoying the sunset. The location is also ideal, within walking distance of great restaurants, shops, and cultural spots. Overall, everything from the service to the ambiance exceeded my expectations. I’d absolutely stay here again and recommend it to anyone visiting the area!

The only thing good about this hotel is the location… besides that I would avoid staying here at ALL COSTS. It literally is not worth it in the slightest. I checked in to have a relaxing weekend in one of my favorite neighborhoods. Upon inspection of my first room, there was marks all over the walls, and there was literal pieces of popcorn all over the pillow and under the bed (on both sides). My first thought was, how when the bed was made perfectly… did they even change these sheets??? I immediately go downstairs and ask for another room. Why did the front desk tell the maintenance crew, my new room number instead of the old one. So I go up to my new room (mind you I am struggling with bags and not one person offered to help at the front desk). I see a man walking into my new room from up the hall and I got really nervous thinking that the assigned me a room that was already occupied. The crew member was apologetic but I just wish there was more clean management of the property. Too much thoughtless things occurred during my stay. Down to me returning the next day from a workout and my card not working in the elevator and having to go to the front desk for them to re-activate it? The process here are clearly outdated and ridden by human error. Which would be understandable if the room was $100 a night but standards are higher when you are spending after $500 a night. Then the second room I checked into had even more marks on the walls and the sink was clogged, toilet ran randomly throughout the night, light near desk was literally broken and just dangling… it felt like an expensive mess. That was the opposite of relaxing, did I mention I was on floor 7 and felt the vibrations of the night club until 1am each night. On my final morning a family checked into the room above me and their child's running woke me up. Mind you, I had been just dealing with all these problems and was not going to even write a review. BUT IT IS OVER TEN DAYS since I checked out and my room deposit still has not been returned to my card (although I have called the hotel multiple times to confirm that my room was cleared for damages). I do not know when my deposit will finally settle but this is absolutely ridiculous especially accounting for the stay that I had. Also, something to note, each time I call the front desk to inquire on the status of my deposit, they all tell me a different standard wait time. First person said 1-3 days, the second said 5 business days, now today the manager on duty said that she doesn’t see my deposit processing on their end… ummm can you loop me in with someone who knows? Just terrible and would never ever recommend!!!!!!!

Room was nice, my only issues were the barn door to the bathroom was falling off and the bottom attachment was broken and my 1 year old kept trying to grab it and the towels were older and frayed (some stained). Service at the hotel lounge downstairs was amazing. We had drinks the other night and breakfast this morning. Both times service was warm and hospitable. I wish we could have enjoyed the rooftop for one last drink, but they wouldn't let us out at 7pm with our 1 year old. The quick view I saw of the city was incredible. Hotel was close proximity to a wedding we went to (within walking distance). I would stay here again, but wish they paid attention to some of the smaller details for the price tag of the room.

Terrible experience. The to go market has very few options and has you going to the bar to pay, be prepared to wait over 15 minutes. Then the eggs were fully rotten. Then I order from the restaurant and the salad tastes like nothing, dressing is yellow water. The guy that takes your car for valet has no company shirt or anything. The room itself is good enough but if you are looking for convenience , not the place.