The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages

For local users exploring "Hotels Near Of Me" with a desire for a luxurious and serene retreat, The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages in Shelter Island, NY, stands out as a distinguished option. Located at 81 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA, this historic property offers a unique blend of classic Hamptons charm and modern amenities. The hotel can be contacted directly at (631) 749-0476 or +1 631-749-0476 for reservations and inquiries.

The environment of The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages is one of its most compelling attributes. Situated on nearly 10 scenic acres of waterfront property overlooking Crescent Beach and the sparkling waters of Long Island Sound, the hotel provides breathtaking views and a sense of exclusive tranquility. Shelter Island itself is known for its "barefoot chic vibes" and "carefree Americana summer style," offering a quieter, more secluded alternative to the bustling Hamptons. The grounds of The Pridwin are meticulously maintained, featuring lush landscaping, Adirondack chairs around fire pits, and rocking chairs on a sprawling wrap-around porch. The property boasts a private beach with sun loungers, towels, and umbrellas, allowing guests direct access to the water. The emphasis on nature and relaxation is palpable, with mentions of "amazing sunsets" and a setting that feels like a "retreat from a lost era." While accessed by a short ferry ride from Sag Harbor or Greenport, this adds to the island's charm and exclusivity, creating a sense of truly "breaking off from reality." For local users seeking "Hotels Near Of Me" that offer a picturesque, waterfront escape with a nostalgic yet updated ambiance, The Pridwin's environment is highly appealing, with strong scores of 9.8 for location and 9.6 for property conditions & facilities from guest reviews.

The services at The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages are designed to provide a comprehensive resort experience. Dining is a significant highlight, with the on-site restaurant, The Terrace, serving "amazing food" with a focus on "classic Long Island food and drink" using "high-quality ingredients sourced from local farms and makers." The restaurant offers breakfast, lunch, and dinner, often with ocean views from its indoor seating and expansive outdoor deck. A lively lounge with water views and a poolside bar ensure that guests have ample options for drinks and socializing. Reviewers rave about the culinary experience, stating, "The food is amazing," and "The drinks are on point." A notable feature is the "Wednesday Night Cookouts" with live music, which adds a vibrant element to the stay. Beyond dining, the hotel offers a full-service spa, The Pridwin Spa, inspired by the healing properties of water, providing a range of treatments including body scrubs, massages, and hydrotherapy. Guests can also enjoy a heated outdoor pool, an indoor gym (including a Peloton bike), tennis and pickleball courts, and complimentary activities such as kayaking, paddleboarding, and bicycles for exploring the island. A free ferry terminal shuttle is also available. While one review noted "service is lacking" during their first weekend open, attributing it to staff being "not very helpful or courteous," the overwhelming majority of recent reviews praise the staff, describing them as "incredibly friendly, helpful and attentive," "exceptional," and going "above and beyond for the best service." This suggests that any initial service inconsistencies have been largely addressed, with a general trend of excellent guest service, reflected in a 9.4 staff & service rating. The hotel also provides a complimentary deluxe continental breakfast each morning.

The features of The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages combine historic elegance with modern comforts, following an extensive two-year renovation that softly launched in mid-summer 2022. The property comprises 33 well-appointed guest rooms within the main hotel building and 16 private cottages. The rooms and cottages are "beautifully furnished," with "nautical accents," "premium bedding," and "signature Pridwin luxury mattresses." Many rooms and all cottages offer "water views" and some cottages include private decks and fireplaces, providing a more private and cozy atmosphere. Bathrooms are modern, with brass fixtures and heated floors in most rooms and cottages. The common areas, described as "beautifully curated," include a "nostalgic front office with key holders," a "history hall" featuring archival photographs, property signage, and hotel mementos from the past nine decades, and an "upper lobby" with vintage chandeliers and a cozy wood-burning hearth, a fully-stocked library, and a large catalog of board games. There's also a dedicated game room for family fun, and a sundries shop named Edie's. The design "playfully refreshed" the historic property, incorporating "contemporary colors like emerald, taffeta pink and white" and rich textiles. The cottages, offering more space and privacy, are particularly appealing for families or extended stays. The hotel also offers practical features like free in-room WiFi, climate-controlled air conditioning and heating, and daily housekeeping. Safety features include carbon monoxide detectors, fire extinguishers, smoke detectors, and first aid kits. The careful attention to detail in the renovation is consistently highlighted by guests, with many mentioning the "beautifully renovated" and "beautifully decorated" spaces. The property is also "Travel Proud" certified, ensuring a welcoming and inclusive environment.

Promotional information for The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages emphasizes its status as a "classic American resort experience" and a "haven of relaxed elegance and luxurious fun." Key selling points revolve around its prime waterfront location, the "amazing sunsets," and the blend of nostalgic charm with modern luxury following its extensive renovation. The hotel actively promotes its comprehensive array of complimentary activities, including kayaks, paddleboards, bikes, tennis, pickleball, and evening s'mores by the fire pits, positioning itself as a destination where "everything was included!" Special packages are frequently offered, such as "What a Difference a Day Makes" for extended stays, "Wednesday Night BBQ Package" with live music and cocktails, and "Sunset Cruise Getaway" featuring rosé and lobster rolls on the hotel's private boat, "Fred's Folly." Other year-round packages include "Pridwin Spa Retreat" and "Dinner on the Terrace." They also have specific offerings like "The Benjamin: $100 Resort Credit" and "Pridwin Pup Retreat" for those traveling with dogs (available in private Birch Cottages). Discounts for AAA & AARP members and "Book Ahead & Save" offers are also common. The on-site spa and farm-to-table dining experience are also significant promotional features, highlighting a focus on wellness and gourmet cuisine. The Pridwin aims to capture the essence of a quintessential Hamptons summer, encouraging guests to "unwind in elegant rooms or private cottages" and "savor cuisine with stunning water views." For local users searching "Hotels Near Of Me," The Pridwin Hotel & Cottages promises a full-service, upscale resort experience on Shelter Island, perfect for a relaxing and activity-filled getaway, blending historical charm with modern comfort and exceptional service.