Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa

For individuals and couples searching for "Hotels Near Of Me" in the picturesque Hudson Valley, particularly seeking a blend of luxury, natural beauty, and a unique experience, Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa stands out as a distinguished option. Located at 220 N Rd, Milton, NY 12547, USA, this resort hotel offers a tranquil retreat just 90 minutes north of New York City. Guests can contact them at (845) 795-1310 or +1 845-795-1310. It's important to provide an objective overview, incorporating both its acclaimed features and areas highlighted in guest feedback.

Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa is set on an expansive 75-acre estate along the Hudson River, providing a serene and picturesque environment. This makes it an ideal destination for those desiring an escape from urban life and seeking connection with nature. The property boasts a working farm, an organic kitchen garden and orchard, trails, and even an an animal rescue sanctuary. Guests can explore lush gardens, witness resident swans on ponds, and interact with various farm animals including alpacas, llamas, donkeys, peacocks, sheep, and goats, many of which are rescued. This unique farm aspect is a significant draw, especially for families or animal lovers. The natural setting, with its river views and extensive grounds, fosters a sense of peace and relaxation.

While offering a secluded feel, the resort is conveniently located within a 15-minute drive of major Hudson Valley attractions such as Marist College and Vassar College, and is also accessible to the Culinary Institute of America. Its proximity to hiking trails like the Rail Trail and scenic parks, along with local art galleries, wineries (like Benmarl Winery), and the Walkway Over the Hudson, ensures that guests have a variety of activities available beyond the immediate property.

Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa offers a comprehensive array of services and amenities designed to cater to a diverse range of guests. These include:

• Accommodation: The resort features 18 individually decorated guest rooms, with 10 located in the main inn building and seven in freestanding carriage houses or private cottages. Rooms often include fireplaces, free WiFi, flat-screen TVs, and private bathrooms with amenities. Some rooms offer garden or river views. Specific options like the North Cottage, Riverbirch House, and Riverknoll Mansion provide more spacious, private accommodations, often with full kitchens and multiple bedrooms, ideal for families or larger groups. Note that children and pets are typically allowed only in the carriage suites and private houses, not in the main inn building.

• Dining: A highlight of the Buttermilk Falls experience is Henry's at the Farm, the on-site farm-to-table restaurant. Henry's is renowned for its contemporary country menu, featuring ingredients sourced directly from the Inn's own Millstone Farm and other local producers. This commitment to fresh, local fare extends to the complimentary cooked-to-order breakfast served daily in the Inn's Sun Room, which includes homemade muffins, eggs from the farm's aviary, and other fresh items. Afternoon tea, with house-made baked goods, is also offered. The restaurant also has a bar/lounge and often provides outdoor seating overlooking the swan pond.

• Buttermilk Spa: The resort's world-class spa is a major draw. It offers a wide range of treatments, including various massages (signature, Swedish, deep tissue, hot stone, maternity, CBD), facials, body treatments, and manicures/pedicures. Spa facilities typically include an indoor "endless current" pool, sauna, steam room, and spa tub. Guests have full access to these spa facilities, providing opportunities for relaxation and rejuvenation.

• Recreational Facilities: Beyond the spa, the property offers an outdoor tennis court, and a well-equipped fitness center. The extensive grounds are perfect for leisurely strolls, birdwatching, and enjoying the natural surroundings. Yoga classes may also be available.

• Weddings and Events: Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa is a popular venue for weddings and other special events. It offers versatile event spaces, including a barn that can accommodate up to 90 guests and various outdoor areas with stunning views for ceremonies and receptions. The staff is often praised for their event planning and execution.

• Pet Policy: The resort is pet-friendly in designated accommodations (carriage suites and houses), with a stated pet cleaning fee (e.g., $25 per pet, per night). However, guests are required to keep pets on a leash and not leave them unattended in rooms, as highlighted in one of the reviews.

• Eco-Friendly Practices: The Inn emphasizes its commitment to sustainability, with its organic farm, orchard, and beehives, providing fresh produce and honey for guests and the restaurant. The animal rescue sanctuary further underscores this commitment.

What truly sets Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa apart in the "Hotels Near Of Me" category is its unique combination of a luxury resort experience with a functional farm and animal sanctuary. This integration offers guests an immersive experience that goes beyond typical hotel stays. The individually decorated rooms, emphasis on farm-to-table dining, and comprehensive spa services all contribute to its distinctive charm. The serene Hudson River setting, combined with the presence of rescue animals, creates an ambiance that is both elegant and endearing. The option for diverse accommodations, from cozy inn rooms to spacious private houses, caters to different preferences and group sizes.

Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa often promotes itself as an ideal destination for romantic getaways, mini-moons, family vacations, and weddings. Guests can typically find booking information and potentially special packages on the resort's official website and through major travel booking platforms. The resort also leverages its unique farm and spa features in its marketing, attracting those interested in wellness, culinary experiences, and nature.

Guest reviews, while generally positive for many aspects, offer a varied perspective. One highly positive review highlights the "amazing, so nice and helpful" staff, praising their attentiveness, assistance with photo spots, and a complimentary bottle of wine for a "mini moon." The breakfast also received praise. This aligns with other reviews that commend the staff's professionalism, kindness, and dedication, especially in the context of events like weddings.

However, another review details significant issues, particularly concerning pet policies and room quality. This guest was "assured verbally and in writing that this establishment welcomed off leash dogs," but was later charged an "extra $800.00 for cleaning the room" after their dog, following heavy rains, required rinsing in the shower. The guest disputes claims of ruined linens, a soiled mattress, or urination, suggesting the charge was a "cash-grab" for room freshening. This review also notes that "no staff is available on the premises overnight," which can be unsettling, especially for single travelers. The guest also mentions being "the only guests I could see on the property" despite lovely weather, implying low occupancy which they attributed to the negative aspects. It's crucial to note that the Inn's official pet policy, as found on their website, explicitly states a $25 per pet, per night cleaning fee and requires pets to be on a leash and not left unattended in rooms. This directly contradicts the guest's claim of being assured off-leash privileges and indicates a significant discrepancy or misunderstanding that led to the substantial charge.

Further, the second reviewer, despite praising Henry's on the Farm, criticized the comfort of the rooms, specifically mentioning an "uncomfortable" bed with "springs in the mattress," "rough sheets," an "uncontrollably hot" room, and "ants in the bathroom." This highlights a potential inconsistency in room quality and maintenance, especially considering the high price point (noted as $400/night).

These reviews collectively suggest that while Buttermilk Falls Inn & Spa excels in its unique environment, farm-to-table dining, and often, its staff service, there might be inconsistencies in guest room quality and a need for clearer communication regarding specific policies, particularly pet policies, to manage guest expectations effectively. Prospective guests searching for "Hotels Near Of Me" seeking a luxurious and unique experience should consider these points and perhaps confirm specific room details and policies directly with the Inn before booking, especially if traveling with pets.