The Sagaponack

Welcome to The Sagaponack, a distinctive hotel situated at 3720 Montauk Hwy, Sagaponack, NY 11962, USA. Perfectly positioned within the picturesque Hamptons, The Sagaponack offers a unique blend of refined comfort and relaxed charm, making it an ideal destination for those seeking a tranquil escape or an adventurous Hamptons experience. As part of the "Hotels Near Of Me" category, The Sagaponack stands out by providing an exceptional experience that caters to both local residents looking for a nearby getaway and travelers exploring the renowned Long Island destination.

The hotel can be reached via phone at (631) 537-0878 or mobile at +1 631-537-0878.

Environment and Ambiance:

The Sagaponack is characterized by its incredibly beautiful facility and well-maintained property. It has undergone a stylish remodel of what was once a motel, transforming it into a charming and inviting retreat. The architecture leans towards a traditional style, creating a timeless appeal. The grounds are lovely and well-kept, contributing to a peaceful and serene atmosphere. Guests consistently praise the clean and well-organized environment, with many noting the quaint feeling that pervades the property. Despite its central location right off Montauk Highway, the hotel manages to maintain a sense of quiet and seclusion, especially during the off-season. The property features an outdoor entertainment area and outdoor furniture, perfect for relaxing and enjoying the Hamptons air. In line with its commitment to a healthy environment, The Sagaponack is a smoke-free property.

Services and Hospitality:

Hospitality is a cornerstone of The Sagaponack experience, with numerous guests highlighting the incredibly welcoming and helpful staff. From seamless check-in processes (some reviews mention being called to confirm arrival) to friendly and accommodating service, the team at The Sagaponack strives to make every guest feel at home. The front desk operates during limited hours, typically from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM, with contactless check-in and check-out options available for convenience. Daily housekeeping service is provided, though guests can opt out to support environmental mindfulness. The hotel also offers concierge services, dry cleaning/laundry service, porter/bellhop assistance, and even wedding services. For families, babysitting services are available for a surcharge, and kid-friendly amenities like a fenced pool and pool gate ensure a safe and enjoyable stay for younger guests. There's also a free area shuttle up to 5 miles, which can be invaluable for exploring the local area without the hassle of driving.

Features and Amenities:

The Sagaponack boasts a comprehensive array of features designed to enhance your stay. A standout amenity is the seasonal outdoor swimming pool, which is open from May to September, typically from 9:00 AM to 8:00 PM. Guests can enjoy sun loungers and pool umbrellas by the poolside. For beach lovers, the hotel offers exclusive beach passes to popular Southampton beaches such as Sagg Main Beach, Mecox Beach, Foster Memorial (Long) Beach, Flying Point Beach, Hot Dog Beach, Tiana Beach, and Pikes Beach. A unique beach locker service is also provided, allowing guests to grab lounge chairs, umbrellas, beach toys, and coolers for their perfect beach day. Complimentary wireless internet access (free in-room and public access) keeps guests connected throughout their stay. Free self-parking and valet parking are available on-site, with wheelchair-accessible parking options. Though there is no on-site restaurant, a well-stocked pantry is open all day, offering freshly baked pastries, yogurt, granola, fresh fruit in the morning, and sweet or savory treats in the afternoon, along with freshly baked cookies and ice cream in the evening. There's also a sophisticated coffee machine and bagged ice available in the breakfast/coffee area, though guests typically take their breakfast to their rooms as there is no designated eating area. A gift shop/newsstand is also on the premises.

Guest rooms, including Main Inn guest rooms, Bungalows, and Studios, are air-conditioned and thoughtfully appointed. They feature luxurious bed linens, plush bathrobes, APOTHEKE White Vetiver bath products, flat-screen TVs (some 32-inch, some 50-inch with Netflix, Hulu, and streaming services), mini-fridges, microwaves, coffee/tea makers, in-room safes, hairdryers, garment steamers, and phones with free local calls. Some rooms also feature kitchenettes. While some guests have noted smaller room sizes, especially for studio rooms, and the absence of trays for breakfast, overall room cleanliness and decor are highly praised. The presence of a sound machine in some rooms is a thoughtful touch.

The Sagaponack is also a pet-friendly hotel, ensuring that furry companions are as comfortable as their owners. There is typically an extra charge for pets, often around USD 75 per accommodation per stay, and pet restrictions apply to specific rooms. For those who enjoy active pursuits, customized priority bikes and e-bikes are available for exploring the scenic surroundings. Lawn games are also available for family and friends.

Features and Promotional Information:

The Sagaponack frequently offers exclusive packages designed to cater to various travel preferences. These include tailored stays for families with young children, providing baby necessities and fun extras for kids, as well as packages that pamper pets traveling with their owners. Discounts and deals are often available throughout the year, with rates varying based on dates and availability. Guests are encouraged to check the hotel's booking channels for the lowest prices and promotional codes. The resort fee, typically around USD 35 per accommodation per night, covers amenities such as beach access, beach loungers, beach towels, housekeeping, pool access, and sporting facilities or equipment.

The hotel's central location in Sagaponack makes it incredibly convenient for accessing local attractions. It is within a short drive of The Hamptons Beaches and close to popular destinations like Wolffer Estates Vineyard (approximately a 3-minute drive or 2.5 km), The Jewish Center of the Hamptons (about 5.5 km), Guild Hall (around 6.4 km), and Georgica Beach (approximately 7.1 km). Other nearby points of interest include Montauk Point Lighthouse (12 miles away), Second House Museum (18 miles), Hither Woods Preserve (18 miles), Fort Pond Bay Park (20 miles), and Shadmoor State Park (20 miles). Guests can also explore local shops, dining options, and cultural institutions like the Parrish Art Museum and LongHouse Reserve. For golf enthusiasts, Poxabogue Golf Course is just 1.5 miles away.

Customer Reviews and Overall Experience:

Overall, The Sagaponack garners very positive reviews, holding an "Excellent" rating of 8.8 based on numerous guest experiences. Guests consistently commend the great location, fair pricing for the Hamptons, clean fresh linens, and comfortable beds. The property is noted for its cleanliness and well-maintained appearance. The staff and service receive high praise for their helpfulness and warmth. Many appreciate the stylish remodel and the thoughtful touches in the rooms, such as the sound machines and high-quality bath products. The pet-friendly policy is a significant positive for those traveling with animals.

However, some reviews point out areas for improvement. Some guests have experienced issues with skylights making it difficult to sleep in, and a few have noted that staff are not on-site after 6 PM, with no response when calling the lobby after hours. There have been comments about some skipped corners/details during the remodel. While many find the rooms cozy, some describe them as "very very tight" or "crammy," particularly the studio rooms, and some have mentioned issues with musty smells or wet carpets, though these appear to be isolated incidents. Breakfast, while appreciated for its sophistication (especially the coffee machine and bagged ice), lacks a designated eating area, requiring guests to dine in their rooms without trays. A few guests have found the pricing to be high, even for the Hamptons, and some have reported hearing noise from other rooms due to thin walls. Despite these minor criticisms, the overarching sentiment is one of enjoyment and satisfaction, with many guests expressing a desire to return for future stays in the Hamptons.